Baseball player Micah Matthias and his young son Bobby are escaping a relentless media pursuit after the traumatic and unsolved murder of their wife and mother. They find refuge in the charming Amish community of Sugarcreek, Ohio, using fake identities and driving an old, run-down truck. Three Amish sisters who run an old farmhouse inn take them in and hire Micah as a handyman. This arouses the suspicions of Rachel Troyler, a policewoman in Sugarcreek and the niece of the three sisters who raised her after she was orphaned as a child. Will the truth hinder their blossoming love?